In brief
- The most common grounds
- False or withheld information, criminal records, pending proceedings, no proof of source of funds, security concerns
- What is usually lost
- Application and due diligence fees; in St Kitts and Nevis they are expressly non-refundable
- What often never falls due
- The investment itself, where it is only payable after approval in principle
- An exception with a guarantee
- Sierra Leone refunds the programme fee from escrow if the naturalisation does not go through
- Last checked
- 14 November 2026
Most applications for citizenship by investment are approved, because they are well prepared and pass the vetting. But not all of them. Anyone looking into a second passport should know what happens if an application is refused, before paying the first fee.
This guide sets out the grounds on which authorities refuse, which payments are then lost, which come back, and why a refusal can have consequences beyond the one programme.
Worried a refusal could affect your own application? Let us review your risks.
Book your consultation nowWhy authorities refuse
The grounds are set out in the programmes’ regulations. The most detailed list is in St Kitts and Nevis, whose 2024 regulations include these points among others:
- False or withheld information in the application
- A criminal record or pending criminal proceedings
- A security risk to the country
- No proof of the source of funds
- Insolvency in the last ten years
- A citizenship that another country has refused
- A visa refused by a country that citizens of St Kitts and Nevis can visit visa-free
On top of that comes an exclusion by nationality. The 2023 Exclusion Order bars nationals and residents of Russia, Belarus, North Korea, Afghanistan, Iraq and Iran from the programme.
On 13 November 2026, St Kitts and Nevis announced that it will wind down its programme. The government is negotiating the timeline with the EU; until then the grounds for refusal and the fees set out here apply.
Other programmes word it similarly, even if their lists are shorter. The core is the same everywhere: identity, background, the source of the money, honesty. What reviewers examine in detail is set out in our piece on due diligence.
Refusal, deferral, query
Not every answer that is not an approval is a refusal. In St Kitts and Nevis, the regulations have the authority report whether an application is approved in principle, refused or deferred for a stated reason.
A deferral is an opportunity. It usually means something is missing or unclear. If you supply it quickly and completely, a deferral can turn into an approval.
More common than either is a simple query during the review: a document, an explanation, a translation. It delays things, but it decides nothing. Left unanswered, however, it can lead to a refusal.
What is lost if you are refused
What a refusal costs depends on when in the procedure each payment falls due. Broadly there are two groups.
Application and due diligence fees
These are paid with the application or shortly afterwards and cover the work of the authority and the vetting firms. In St Kitts and Nevis, the application and due diligence fees are expressly non-refundable.
For a single applicant that means a 250 USD application fee and a 10,000 USD due diligence fee, plus 7,500 USD for each dependant aged 16 and over.
For other programmes, too, you should assume these fees are lost. Count them as the price of the attempt, not as a deposit.
The agent’s fee
What happens to your agent’s fee is not set by the programme but by your contract. Some providers charge part of it only on success. Read that clause before you sign.
Unsure which of your payments would be at risk? Let us walk through them.
Book your consultation nowWhat often never falls due
The good news lies in the sequence. In many programmes you pay the investment only after approval in principle. If the application is refused before that, the large sum has never left your account.
- St Kitts and Nevis: the investment follows within 90 days of approval in principle.
- São Tomé and Príncipe: the donation to the National Transformation Fund is due after approval in principle.
- Vanuatu: payment is split, 25 percent before the Commission’s review and 75 percent before the certificate is issued.
The real estate route is different. In St Kitts and Nevis you sign the binding purchase agreement before filing. What happens to that agreement if you are refused is then decided by your contract with the developer. Check that clause particularly carefully.
An exception with a refund guarantee: Sierra Leone
Sierra Leone works differently from the Caribbean. The programme fee goes at the outset into a lawyer’s escrow account and stays there until naturalisation.
If the naturalisation cannot be completed, the programme fee is refunded in full. The exceptions are the submission and processing costs, such as the vetting, the notary and the lawyer. Every detail is on the Sierra Leone page.
Would an escrow arrangement suit your plans better? We can explore it together.
Book your consultation nowA worked example: what a refusal costs
The size of the loss is clearest for a family of four: a married couple, one child aged 17 and one aged 10. The figures come from the two programmes’ fee schedules.
St Kitts and Nevis, Sustainable Island State Contribution:
| Item | Amount | If refused before approval in principle |
|---|---|---|
| Application fee, 4 × 250 USD | 1,000 USD | lost |
| Due diligence fee, main applicant | 10,000 USD | lost |
| Due diligence fee, spouse and child aged 16+, 2 × 7,500 USD | 15,000 USD | lost |
| Contribution | 250,000 USD | not yet paid |
So 26,000 USD is lost, while the 250,000 USD contribution never left the account.
Sierra Leone, Fast Track with family: the 4,750 USD submission fee and the 5,000 USD processing fee, 9,750 USD in total, are lost. The programme fee sits in escrow and comes back if the naturalisation does not go through.
Both examples show the same thing: the price of a refusal is manageable if it comes early. It gets expensive when money has gone into a property before the decision.
What a refusal means for later applications
This is the point many people overlook. A refusal does not stay within the programme that issued it.
St Kitts and Nevis expressly lists a citizenship refused by another country as a ground for refusal.
If you were refused in one programme and try the next, assume the new review will find out, and answer the question about it truthfully.
That does not make a second application hopeless. It means that the reason for the first refusal must be resolved before you apply again. Filing the same case unchanged elsewhere is very likely to fail again.
And it means: keeping quiet is not an option. A concealed refusal is itself a ground for refusal, and it can put a citizenship granted later at risk.
Refused before and considering another programme? Let us assess your next step together.
Book your consultation nowWhat to do after a refusal
Understand the reason
Ask your agent to find out the reason for the refusal as precisely as possible. Not every authority gives details. But the queries raised during the review often show what went wrong. Keep every letter from the authority and from your agent; they are the basis for every next step, including a later application.
Assess the case honestly
If a document was missing, the case can be repaired. If it was a criminal record, a sanctions link or an insolvency, a new programme will not change the underlying problem.
Close the gap first, then plan again
If proof of the source of funds was missing, build it before going any further. How to do that is shown in our guide to proving the source of funds. Only then is it worth asking which programme fits.
Look at alternatives to investment
For some cases another route makes more sense: naturalisation through residence, descent or marriage. These routes have their own checks, but different criteria.
How to avoid a refusal
Most refusals have reasons that can be spotted beforehand. An honest preliminary check is therefore the most important investment before you apply:
- Do your CV, tax records and account balances match?
- Are there proceedings, visa refusals or insolvencies in your past?
- Is your nationality or your country of residence among those excluded?
- Are all dependants aged 16 and over as unproblematic as you are?
If you answer these questions beforehand, you can choose a programme whose rules fit your case rather than one that will fail on it.
The rules for St Kitts and Nevis are on the St Kitts and Nevis page, with their sources.
Bottom line: the refusal starts before the application
A refusal is expensive, but rarely a matter of chance. Almost always, the problem was visible before filing. If you find and solve it there, you save fees, time and an entry that would follow you into every later application.
Sources
- Saint Christopher and Nevis: Citizenship by Substantial Investment Regulations, S.R.O. No. 20 of 2024 (grounds for refusal, fees, deadlines)
- Saint Christopher and Nevis: Citizenship By Investment (Exclusion) Order, S.R.O. No. 27 of 2023
- sierraleonepassport.com: escrow and refund guarantee
- Citizenship by Investment Programme São Tomé and Príncipe: Investment Structure (payment after approval)
What this means for you
A refusal costs fees and time, and it follows you: at least one programme expressly asks about a citizenship refused before. The best strategy is therefore not to risk a refusal at all, with an honest, complete file and a programme that fits your case.
If a refusal is already on the cards for you, we look with you in a consultation at which routes remain open.
Book a consultation